Pennsylvania's Sunshine Act requires government agencies to provide public access to meeting agendas at least 24 hours prior to the meeting. The agenda must list all issues to be discussed or acted on, and agencies cannot discuss or act on non-agenda issues. This rule is subject to three exceptions: (1) emergency matters, (2) de minimis matters (of little importance) that arise within 24 hours of a meeting that do not involve public funds or creation of a contract, and (3) matters raised by a resident or taxpayer during a meeting which may be referred to staff or added to a future agenda, or discussed and acted on if they are de minimis and do not involve public funds or creation of a contract.
The law also states that an agency may add an issue to the agenda during the meeting if approved by a majority vote after an announcement and an opportunity for public comment. This provision was intended to provide a procedure for amending the agenda consistent with one of the three exceptions listed above.
Back in 2021, Sen. Jarrett Coleman (R-Lehigh) sued Parkland School District Board of Directors over its decision to add a vote approving a teachers union contract, that was ratified by the union earlier in the day, to its agenda during its meeting.
But, in that case, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court has interpreted this procedural provision to be a separate, fourth exception to the 24-hour rule for agendas. The court's interpretation effectively means that an agency can add any issue to the agenda at the last minute – even during a meeting – as long as a majority of agency members approve. This interpretation is contrary to the intent of the agenda requirements and the purpose of the Sunshine Act, which is to provide the public advance notice about proposed government actions so that they can make an informed decision about whether to attend and participate in the process.
There is pending legislation designed to restore public transparency and tighten the Sunshine Act's agenda requirements. I urge the state assembly to act swiftly.
Two examples of what can happen when local governing bodies add important items to the agendas at the last minute include: the Greater Latrobe School Board in suburban Pittsburgh, one month after the ruling came down, added a vote to hire a new solicitor to its agenda, and a borough council voting to dissolve a fire department with no prior notice that the action was under consideration.
It is the Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association's opinion that the legislature must pass a meaningful law that would allow government entities to only amend meeting agendas after the 24-hour deadline for limited, narrow reasons.