Several Charges Held For County Court Against Douglass Twp. Supervisor
In October, one month after his first arrest, embattled Douglass Township supervisor Frederick W. Ziegler initiated a conversation with police Chief Barry Templin.
The law enforcement official said he was expecting a conversation about police detail at an upcoming Halloween parade.
Instead, Templin testified Tuesday that Ziegler announced he was doing his own investigation into charges that he stole municipal property for personal use.
According to the chief, Ziegler displayed an angry demeanor during the meeting. Templin said a heated exchange ensued. "I got very upset," Templin said under oath. "I lost my temper."
After several continuances, Collegeville District Judge Cathleen Kelly Rebar officiated a consolidated preliminary hearing against Ziegler.
After listening to more than five hours of argument and testimony from nine witnesses, Rebar held over all but one of the charges in two separate incidents for the Montgomery County Common Pleas Court.
The judge dismissed four felony charges of Restricted Activities - Accept Improper Influence. She ordered Ziegler, 62, to stand trial in county court on charges of theft by unlawful taking, receiving stolen property, intimidation and retaliation against witnesses, forgery, unsworn falsification to authorities, tampering with public records obstruction of administrative law and conflict of interest from September 2012 to the end of 2014.
"I'm very pleased with the outcome," said John Flannery Jr., the deputy Pennsylvania attorney general prosecuting the case. "Frederick Ziegler is a township supervisor who pilfered township property for his own uses and used township employees for his own personal bidding. All of that is against the law."
Vincent DiFabio, Ziegler's defense attorney, said he respect Rebar's decision, but vowed to fight the charges at county court. "These charges have very little substance to them," DiFabio said after the hearing.
Flannery called eight witnesses. They included officials from Douglass Township: Cynthia O'Donnell, the appointed treasurer; township Manager Pete Hiryak, road master Mike Heydt and Templin.
According to law enforcement officials, Ziegler initially stole plywood, a chainsaw, a propane tank and illegally utilized a municipal gas card for his personal vehicle between August of 2012 and November of 2013.
DiFabio argued unsuccessfully that his client lawfully borrowed the new chainsaw, which he broke and replaced approximately 18 months later, to clear trees on his property related to a drainage problem created several years ago by municipal officials.
The defense attorney claimed that since township officials never asked his client to reimburse the municipality for four unauthorized fuel purchases, authorities cannot prove an intent to deprive.
According to DiFabio, Ziegler gave Hiryak a blank check to cover the cost of the plywood on Nov. 20, 2013 – the same day a group of township officials met with Montgomery County detectives to discuss the situation.
The manager said he never filled in an amount on the check. Flannery called the issuance "self-serving, just like everything else Mr. Ziegler has done in this case."
Heydt testified that Ziegler took the 100-gallon propane tank, paid for with township funds, saying that he wanted to utilize it at his hunting cabin in New York. The supervisor replaced the tank with two smaller tanks, according to Heydt.
In January authorities rearrested Ziegler, a former police chief in Douglass Township who also worked as an investigator for the Montgomery County's Extradition Unit, on refiled charges of the unlawful use of a Montgomery County Court subpoena and attempted intimidation of Hiryak, a witness in the initial case against him.
Less than a month after the September 2 arrest, Ziegler, accompanied by supervisors Chairman John Stasik, Jr., demanded an impromptu meeting with Hiryak at the township building, according to court papers.
In the meeting, Ziegler announced he was conducting his own investigation, and that the supervisor began to question the manager about his personal and professional life, authorities claim. With two out of three supervisors present, Hiryak felt compelled to answer the questions, the document states.
On Oct. 1, Ziegler again returned to the township building at 1320 East Philadelphia Ave. and demanded another meeting with Hiryak. The supervisor wanted to discuss allegations of Ziegler stealing shotguns from the Douglass Township Police Department and buying a rifle at Pachella Arms without paying for it, according to the affidavit.
It states that Ziegler showed Hiryak a copy of the allegedly forged subpoena and receipts from the gun dealer, along with a copy of the report he obtained from the Boyertown police.
Hiryak told authorizes he "felt uncomfortable, cautious, and on guard speaking to Ziegler" on Oct. 1.On Tuesday, DiFabio argued that the conflict of interest charges have no merit because Hiryak displayed no evidence of intimidation in his testimony. Rebar rejected that argument.
Less than a week later, following a public supervisors meeting on Oct. 6, Templin met with Ziegler inside the conference room at the township building. During the meeting Ziegler announced he was doing his own investigation of his case, according to Templin's testimony.
Holding a file folder, and standing next to the table covered with copies of subpoenas he obtained from the Montgomery County's Prothonotary office, Ziegler said: "I don't know if you are my friend. I don't think you are my friend."
Templin stood up. He testified that he lost his temper.
"I don't give a [expletive] what you think," the police chief said, according to his testimony.
The police chief testified that he called Ziegler a liar during the exchange. According to Templin, Ziegler told him the case against him had been dropped in the same day he learned it had been referred by the DA to the state attorney general's office.
A formal arraignment in Norristown has been scheduled for June 10, according to the judge.